Compilation: The Evidence For EBEs

Evidence Description:
The 'Tin Foil Alien'...
From the source:
"This strange account began when Falkville, Alabama police chief Jeff Greenhaw ( that is correct, there is no s after the n) received a phone call from an excited lady who said that she had witnessed a "spaceship" land in an open field not far the town proper. Greenhaw took off like a shot, taking along his trusty Polaroid camera. Dark had fallen several hours earlier, and the police chief was armed for anything. It would be about 10:00 P.M. when he made it to the location of the alleged landing..."

Chief Greenhaw comes across the alien, snaps several pictures, and the Alien flees when he turns on his trucks headlights. He pursues the Alien to no avail...

The report is dated: October 17, 1973


Evidence Source:
ufocasebook.com...


Evidence:
image source: http://www.ufocasebook.com/tinfoilalien.jpg



ATS Thread(s) Pertaining to Evidence:
http://www.abovetopsecret.com/forum/thread197449/pg1






[edit on 17-12-2007 by WitnessFromAfar]

EVIDENCE DESCRIPTION:
Dorothy Wilkinson-Izatt's photographic images of beings from other worlds.

From the source:
"Since 1974, Dorothy Wilkinson-Izatt has been recording strange phenomenon on Super 8 home movie film. To call it UFO contact, would only be partially right. The footage not only captures alien craft, and at times occupants, but other unusual events that seem to disregard the laws of physics.

There are photographs of amazing light shows that pale the efforts of Hollywood special effects technicians. Others reveal scenes of what can best be described as 'space/dimension warps', a common method of travel and communication for our otherworldly (??) friends.

To date, the films have been examined and studied by some of the worlds foremost experts, and as yet, no definitive answers have been reached. Theories and hypothesis abound, but on one thing the experts agree, something very real is happening that defies our understanding of the natural laws and shakes the foundation of our belief structures."


EVIDENCE SOURCE:
http://www.manari.ca/index.html
http://www.timelessvoyager.com/cwbol.htm
http://www.capturingthelightdvd.com/
http://www.amazon.com/Contact-Beings-Light-Amazing-Wilkinson-Izatt/dp/1892264137/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1197928241&sr=1-1
Dorothy Izzak and Dr. J. Allen Hynek

EVIDENCE:
One of Dorothy's frameshots from one of her movies:


ATS discusion thread on her work:
http://www.abovetopsecret.com/forum/thread319622/pg1


[edit on 17-12-2007 by Palasheea]

Evidence Description:
Alien In Suit On The Moon???
This piece of evidence comes from NASA photography. Photograph taken by Gene Cernan, with the Hasselblad 60mm lens and color film.
It looks from careful examination like this was just a different type of NASA Spacesuit, although it looks distinctly different on initial viewing...


Evidence Source:
p086.ezboard.com...
img60.echo.cx...


Evidence:
image source: http://www.hq.nasa.gov/alsj/a17/AS17-137-20900.jpg

Another, smaller image is here:
http://www.hq.nasa.gov/alsj/a17/20117199.jpg
A side by side comparison of this alleged 'Alien' and NASA Astronaut Harrison Schmidt in full suit (the astronaut supposedly in the picture) is here:
image source: http://img60.echo.cx/img60/3496/comparison1station22am.jpg

In debunking, from the thread:
"The mysterious spacesuit is from one of the Apollo missions
it is the A7L" - MuzzleFlash
Pic accompanying MuzzleFlash's claim is here:
image source: http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v201/muzzleflash5588/suitsolved.jpg



ATS Thread(s) Pertaining to Evidence:
http://www.abovetopsecret.com/forum/thread147219/pg1

reply to post by Palasheea

---

NOW THAT'S WHAT I'M TALKING ABOUT!!!
(WitnessFromAfar Jumps Up and Down Excitedly That Someone Else Followed The Format Perfectly and Added A New Piece of Evidence!!!)
Thanks Palasheea, I didn't see this one in my searching

[edit on 17-12-2007 by WitnessFromAfar]

Oh, I'm so relieved! I didn't know if it was ok to add anything here but if I find anything else then I'll post it here.
Dorothy Izzaks images probably fall into the EME (Extraterrestrial Materialized Entities) category but as such things go, we really don't know for sure -- they could be EBE's too. Some of her images were more 'solid' than others.
Great idea putting all of this information in one thread, btw!

reply to post by Palasheea

---

It is absolutely OK!!! Thanks for contributing, and for you compliment. Even if people just posted a link to a new piece of evidence I'd be pleased, but you went all out with a report and everything! I'm officially having a good day!

Lol, you poor thing you! You've been doing all this work because most of us were unclear if we could help you out with this!

Great to know that there's no problem with that because I've got quite a few that I would like to add here -- though some will be more in the EME category but good that it's ok to post those too! This will allow for a more comprehensive collection of such images IMHO.

Evidence Description:

Back in 1995, a tragic car accident occurred in Hillsborough County, Florida which resulted in the death of an 18 yr. old male and critically injuring another. A staff photographer from Tampa Times took photo's of that accident where it was shown in that paper the next day. On the second of December of this year (2007), a new ATS member, NeverWalkAlone, started up a new thread in the Paranormal Studies forum to talk about that papers' photograph taken of this accident because 2 anomalous faces showed up in it where one of those images/faces looked like "something outside of this world".

I, the writer of this post, contacted the Tampa Times photographer of this photo, Candace Mundy, and asked her if she remembers anything about this photo that she took of that accident. Below is her reply:
Wow, now this is the STRANGEST thing I have ever received, I must say……I have pondered the photo, but honestly I can’t remember anything…..I would love to see the original print…..sure is interesting. To me it looks as if the woman could be real, but the man, I don’t know, I would have to agree with others that indeed he looks like something out of hell!

I wish I could be more help. Sure is something though.

I will read more of this and see what comes……

Thanks for sending me the info…..

Candace Mundy

note: I also sent her a link to the ATS thread that was discussing this photograph for her to view.

Evidence Source:
http://www.abovetopsecret.com/forum/thread318832/pg2

Evidence:

note: Notice the male face that's to the left of the woman in the white coat that is in that ZOOM of that section in this photograph were that face appeared.

Here is the OP's sketch of that STRANGE face seen in that photo:


ATS Thread(s) Pertaining to Evidence:
http://www.abovetopsecret.com/forum/thread318832/pg2



[edit on 17-12-2007 by Palasheea]

Evidence Description:
Security Camera Footage of an Alien Abduction???
From one thread:
"It is a security video from what appears to be a store. The time is 11.16pm and a worker is seemingly closing up the place for the night. However, when he opens the back gate and walks outside there is an instant, blinding flash right where he is standing and then all of the security cameras are temporarily knocked out, soon resuming their function. They then run for another 1 hour 50 minutes until 1.06am when there is another blinding white flash and all the cameras again get knocked out. When they resume function the aforementioned worker can be seen lying in a foetal position nearby to where he disappeared. He then leans up, vomits, then staggers off disorientated." -Posted by Lightunseen


Evidence Source:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QkeOUzKRzLY


Evidence:

YouTube Link

ATS Thread(s) Pertaining to Evidence:
http://www.abovetopsecret.com/forum/thread314049/pg1
http://www.abovetopsecret.com/forum/thread302902/pg1

Evidence Description:
Alien Filmed at the Zoo???
WOW. Just plain old wow. Not for the video itself, but for the debating threads...
It seems that MANY ATS posters think they know what this is.
1) An Alien
2) A Blade of Grass
3) A Skeleton Toy (popular in mexico...)
4) An artifact caused by recording over an existing recording...

The list goes on and on. I'm honestly not sure what this video shows, so I find it best to include it here. There is a lot of debate at the threads for this piece...

Evidence Source:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zXiFaG4TmRw

Evidence:

YouTube Link

ATS Thread(s) Pertaining to Evidence:
http://www.abovetopsecret.com/forum/thread289902/pg1
http://www.abovetopsecret.com/forum/thread288267/pg1

Evidence Description:
Russian Fisherman Catch Alien and Eat It???
NOPE, this one is actually quite terrestrial. It's all over the internet and ATS as an alien though, so I thought it should be posted here for clarity.
This is a Skate, similar to a MantaRay or StingRay...


Evidence Source:
PRAVDA ~Warning, this article is from PRAVDA~
english.pravda.ru...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6tfTMjYsS-U


Evidence:
The video is here:
http://www.fark.ru/media/video/prikols6/i1645
Here is a pic of a Skate (submitted by Crakeur), for comparison:
http://www.fotosearch.com/comp/IGS/IGS548/IS262-023.jpg
Here is the youtube video for comparison

YouTube Link

ATS Thread(s) Pertaining to Evidence:
http://www.abovetopsecret.com/forum/thread266428/pg1
http://www.abovetopsecret.com/forum/thread266553/pg1



[edit on 17-12-2007 by WitnessFromAfar]

[edit on 17-12-2007 by WitnessFromAfar]

Evidence Description:
Cunninghham Video - Mental Wealth - 'Alien Girl'
This video is new to me, and REALLY convincing, without of course reading the accompanying ATS Thread, where it's totally explained. This video was filmed for a 2000 Playstation Commercial.
The making of the Video is here:
http://www.director-file.com/cunningham/sony.html

More of (Director) Cunningham's work can be seen here:
http://www.director-file.com/cunningham/aphex2k.jpg
http://www.director-file.com/cunningham/rubberpromo4.jpg
He's one freaky guy!

This video also made me think of the one person I've ever met that I thought just might be a hybrid. First and foremost, I don't mean to slander this girl in any way. I used to work in the Fashion industry, and got to meet a lot of models. The girl in this video reminded me of Gemma Ward. Now, if Gemma is a hybrid (and I'm not saying she is...) she's one of the nicest beings I've ever met, and is not here to dominate the Earth Although as one of Earth's premier models, I suppose she does sort of rule! Here's some info on Gemma (who may have been the inspiration for this Alien-Girl Character, at least visually):
en.wikipedia.org...
And a pic (NOTE This is a Model Named Gemma, not the 'Alien-Girl' in the video):
image source: http://www.theimagist.com/files/images/GemmaGemma.jpg

NOTE: Gemma Ward is not an alien! (that I know of LOL). She's a really nice girl and her pic is only here as an illustrative comparison...


Evidence Source:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wpBPi4CjDMQ
http://www.director-file.com/cunningham/sony.html


Evidence:

YouTube Link

Picture of the real girl (Fiona Maclean) side by side with the created image:
image source: http://www.director-file.com/cunningham/fifimoon.jpg



ATS Thread(s) Pertaining to Evidence:
http://www.abovetopsecret.com/forum/thread308851/pg1

Evidence Description:
Flaming Head Alien on Brazil Roadway???
Here is another example of how realistic a video can look, and how much ATS kicks butt at research! This 'Alien' is in fact CGI...

From the Thread:
"The "creature" is a CGI character made by the artist Eduardo Schaal for Trattoria di Frame productions, São Paulo, Brazil"
-Internos

More from the Thread:
"The Curupira is a mythological creature from the Brazilian forests..."
-ArMaP
Info on Curupira here:
en.wikipedia.org...

Info on the Artist is here:
http://www.ceticismoaberto.com/fotos/fotofantasma61.htm
http://www.ceticismoaberto.com/news/?cat=13&paged=4
planeta.terra.com.br...
neminventonemaumento.zip.net...

The CGI was revealed here by the producer:
neminventonemaumento.zip.net...


Evidence Source:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QQq4q8PWCoU


Evidence:

YouTube Link

CGI Model:
image source: http://img230.imageshack.us/img230/1549/trattoriayn1.jpg

image source: http://img216.imageshack.us/img216/1923/trattoria2yc1.jpg

Here is another video by the same author that seems to use the same CGI model without the flames:

YouTube Link

ATS Thread(s) Pertaining to Evidence:
http://www.abovetopsecret.com/forum/thread317303/pg1



[edit on 18-12-2007 by WitnessFromAfar]

Evidence Description:
Alien Head Found In Duck Stomach???
In fact it was grain, but this pic caused a huge sensation in the news and here at ATS. Even debunked, this item certainly belongs in this thread...
Autopsy of Duck:
http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2006/05/26/DUCK.TMP


Evidence Source:
http://www.ufocasebook.com/alienduck.html
atsmedia.cachefly.net...
http://www.foxreno.com/news/9273530/detail.html


Evidence:
image source: http://atsmedia.cachefly.net/uploads/ats33296_Alieninduck_large.jpg

image source: http://www.ufocasebook.com/alienduck.jpg



ATS Thread(s) Pertaining to Evidence:
http://www.abovetopsecret.com/forum/thread209965/pg1
http://www.abovetopsecret.com/forum/thread209357/pg2

Report:

Okay, I'm at my first real stopping point in this search for Evidence of EBEs. At this point, I've done an exhaustive search through the ATS search function, for the word 'Alien'. I've been through 1000 entries, and the evidence found there (with a few additions by other ATS posters) is listed above this entry in this thread. After 100 pages of search results (10 results per page), I've come to the end of this particular search. Counting an average of 3 pages per thread, 3000 pages of potential 'evidence' has now been reduced to these 4 pages of 'Evidence' entries, and has been catalouged for research. I have found several dozen multiple entries (several threads per piece of evidence [or topic/issue]), and several dozen threads with no actual 'evidence' posted, as fits the criteria for this thread.

Next, I plan to perform similar searches, for the keywords; EBE, EBEN, Extraterrestrial, etc. If additional (non-repeating) evidence is exposed through these searches, this data will be added here next.

If any ATS member knows of a piece of Evidence I've missed here, please either post it in this thread or U2U me.

More to come soon!

-Witness From Afar

I know it's been a lot of effort, but what you've accumulated here is a kind of hodgepodge of junk, a lot of it barely qualifying as "evidence," none of it conclusive, and some of it downright laughable. Gathering all of this stuff doesn't account for much, because a thousand bad reports will never amount to one good one.

I think it's more important to understand exactly why none of the things you've presented amount to workable proof of ET life. Otherwise I might as well offer the Gidney and Cloyd characters from "Rocky and Bullwinkle," or the Quisp alien or the green actors from "Santa Claus vs. the Martians" as "evidence" of EBEs.



Are we being conditioned for disclosure!!??

reply to post by Nohup

---

Hello, and thanks for your reply.
I would tend to generally agree with your sentiment, that there does not appear to be a smoking gun here, so far...

I would like to briefly re-state that I do not endorse any of these items as 'real' or 'authentic' evidence of EBEs.

What I do claim, is that this is the bulk of the 'evidence' available on the subject. I also claim that checking this one thread is a thousand (or 3000 depending on how much research LOL) times easier than digging through ATS archives for the same results.

This project is for everyone's clarity. I'm glad that the results have brought clarity to you Nohup.

I'm not sure how a cartoon character would compare with any of these pieces of evidence, but perhaps I just don't understand your point, no offense intended...

As for 'evidence' itself, and what qualifies...
Evidence (in a court of law) is used to determine the validity of a claim.
The evidence itself is key, even if it has been faked. Evidence (including fakery) can lead to a solid conclusion on the outcome of a mystery. Thus, compiling the evidence (in my view) is the necessary first step in attempting to solve this mystery.

As for my personal beliefs (even though they are not relevant to this thread, which is about catalouging data) I have never seen an EBE (to my knowledge) in person. I'm not sure what one would look like, or how one would manifest itself to our perception. I have seen several craft in the sky, some of which could be Government Black Ops, some of which could be Natural Phenomenon, and at least 3 of which I'm prepared to say were Extraterrestrial Spaceships (note, not UFOs, these 3 I think were indeed craft). I do not have evidence of my own personal sightings to display for you, however I'm not seeking to prove my experiences to anyone, it's not my intent. I'm just looking for answers. This thread (and other compilations I plan to undertake) has helped me personally to understand just what 'evidence' is actually out there. It has also given me quick access to stories that are doubtless to come up here at ATS again in the future, with resources immediately available now to provide if/when these issues come to light.

I hope that clearly illustrates my postition here. I'm not trying to pull the wool over anyone's eyes, just trying to see what's out there.

Thanks again for your reply Nohup, I hope you can understand the value of this Compilation, and hopefully you can find a piece or two of evidence from your own searches to add here to the mix!

-Witness From Afar

Evidence Description:
Picture of Alien in Alaska???
From the source:
"The picture was taken in the early 1930s by the sender's grandfather, who lived in Alaska. The entitiy was first seen when the grandfather was on his way to a lake. He chased the entity until he got close enough to take this one picture. It was some four months before the photograph was developed, being in in a remote, sparsely populated area. The sender received the picture from his grandfather only last week His grandfather died the day after giving him the photo, and relating his story."


Evidence Source:
http://www.ufocasebook.com/alaskaalien.html


Evidence:
The Original Photo:
image source: http://www.ufocasebook.com/alaska30s.png

Photo Analysis by: KingLizard
image source: http://img45.exs.cx/img45/5017/alien.jpg



ATS Thread(s) Pertaining to Evidence:
http://www.abovetopsecret.com/forum/thread64684/pg1

Sorry, as I said, I don't see the value in it, because you've failed to provide any quality controls as to what is considered "evidence." Should we include Fred Flintstone's "Great Gazoo" as "evidence" of aliens? Drag out the entire Zacharia Sitchin library? Rehash the Bible and the Apocrypha (again and again)?

I would see much more value with taking a particularly interesting case or cases, such as the Pascagoula abduction or the Lonnie Zamora sighting, and examining exactly where the available data falls short of providing actual proof. That would be educational, particularly for the folks who like to think that every blurry bird or hydrocephalic baby skull is proof positive of aliens.

Thread flagged and starred, as it is a noble effort to collate the available data on this most curious of subjects. However, I fear you guys have an uphill struggle. It is SO difficult to ascertain which of these cases you have presented here are real, if any, due to the misidentification cases as mentioned in the post by Nohup, and blatant hoaxes that abound on the internet.

There are some pictures, and I mean literally two out of the many I have seen that make me feel funny. By that I mean slightly quickening heart rate and a sense of deja vu, but I don't read anything into this other than the fact they look real and as such are a little unnerving.

Carry on with your efforts, don't be dissuaded, and maybe, just maybe you will find 'the one'.

Regards and good luck,

Chris.